Importers get two more years on methane rules

EU methane rules for oil, gas and coal importers delayed to 2029

If you import natural gas, oil or coal into the EU, the methane rules now give you two more years before you must prove how much methane leaked on the way. A provisional deal reached on 19 November moves the first deadline for importers from 1 January 2027 to 1 January 2029. Reporting on methane intensity, the leak rate per unit of fuel, moves from 5 August 2028 to 5 August 2030 for importers and EU producers alike.

Table of contents
  1. A law barely two years old
  2. A request that travelled in five months
  3. Parliament tripled the offer
  4. What two years actually moves in the methane rules
  5. The argument for the delay
  6. Who pays for the time

The deal still needs formal backing from Parliament and Council, due by the end of the year. But the pattern is already visible: an industry and a group of governments asked for a delay of three years, and the law’s own deadlines now sit two years later than the ones written in 2024.

A law barely two years old

The methane regulation (Regulation (EU) 2024/1787) was adopted in May 2024 and entered into force in August 2024. It makes importers prove that the oil, gas and coal they bring in was produced under monitoring rules equivalent to the EU’s own, for supply contracts signed or renewed since 4 August 2024. The reporting duty for EU operators in Article 27 has applied since 5 May 2025 and was left untouched by the Commission’s proposal.

The delay therefore targets the part of the law that reaches beyond the EU’s borders. The proof sits with importers, and it concerns how fuel is produced outside the EU.

A request that travelled in five months

The request is documented. On 25 June, twelve member states (Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Czechia, Hungary, Italy, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland, Romania, Slovakia and Sweden) put a note before the energy ministers asking for “targeted amendments” that would postpone the importer obligations by three years. The note called a non-binding Commission recommendation not to fine importers insufficient.

The day before, on 24 June, an open letter had gone to EU leaders. It was signed by US Energy Secretary Chris Wright and the energy ministers of Qatar, Nigeria and Algeria, and Kazakhstan and Guyana joined on 23 October. The ministers of Qatar, Algeria and Nigeria told EU leaders there was “no viable path to compliance”.

France joined in September, when President Macron wrote to Commission President von der Leyen urging a delay. Czech Industry Minister Karel Havlicek said Czechia had won “19 other countries over to its side”. The Commission had already proposed in July to waive penalties for three years, and on 14 October it proposed a one-year postponement of the importer rules.

Read also: Europe’s Gas Storage Target Bends to 70%

The Commission is reported to justify the delay by disruption to Gulf energy flows, including the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, which hit a significant share of global LNG supply and seaborne oil trade. Importers argued that they risked not finding enough compliant supply by the scheduled date.

Parliament tripled the offer

On 22 October Parliament voted 341 to 225, with 6 abstentions, for a three-year delay. The centre-right EPP pushed the vote. Its spokesman Christian Ehler called the Commission’s one year “far from sufficient”. Greens negotiator Jutta Paulus called the outcome “an absolute scandal”, and said conservatives had joined the far right to weaken a climate law.

Social Democrats and Liberals had backed the one-year delay before the vote. Parliament also wanted importers to show only by 31 May 2031 that contracts signed or renewed since 4 August 2024 cover fuel produced under equivalent monitoring rules.

The governments went the other way. On 6 November the Council backed the Commission’s one year, with a review by 30 September 2027 that could defer the importer duties again through secondary legislation. The deal of 19 November lands between the two: two years, more than the Commission and the governments offered, less than Parliament demanded.

What two years actually moves in the methane rules

Headlines say the rules are delayed until 2029. That is the date for the first monitoring, reporting and verification duty on importers. Methane-intensity reporting moves to 2030, for importers and EU producers alike.

Set side by side, the three positions look like this. The original law required importer monitoring from 1 January 2027, intensity reporting from 5 August 2028 and maximum intensity limits from 5 August 2030. The Commission and the Council wanted each date moved by one year, to 2028, 2029 and 2031. The deal moves the first two by two years, to 2029 and 2030, and says nothing yet about the third.

One gap stands out. The Council’s announcement does not give a new date for the maximum methane-intensity limits that the regulation promises for later, and it does not say that penalties have been waived. Whether the 2031 date from the one-year version still holds is left unstated in the text published with the deal.

The Commission must now review how the regulation works in practice, including the rules for third-party verifiers and security of supply, by 1 January 2028. The 2027 review in the Council’s one-year version could defer the importer duties again, and the review date in this deal is the next point where the timetable can be reopened.

The argument for the delay

The case for the delay deserves a fair hearing. Importers warned legislators that they might not secure enough supply that meets the new verification standard. Dimitris Tsiodras, the EPP’s negotiator in Parliament, says the delay secures the regulation’s “effective implementation” and lets all compliance requirements be met in practice. Francois-Regis Mouton de Lostalot of the oil and gas producers’ association IOGP calls the outcome a “certain improvement”.

Read also: Europe tightens Russia sanctions while America loosens them

The Commission says the agreement preserves the overall ambition, integrity and scope of the regulation. The Irish presidency’s minister, Darragh O’Brien, spoke of a pragmatic balance. Methane stays in the law, and the Council describes the change as a postponement of dates, not a repeal.

Lea Pilsner of Environmental Defense Fund Europe was “in a way pleased” that governments backed the shorter delay. Her warning concerned the review clause in the Council’s version, which she said “opens the door to many further delays” at unclear times.

Who pays for the time

Environmental groups and experts question whether the postponement achieves anything that the original dates could not. Pilsner says governments “bought themselves two years the regulation never needed”, and that the integrity of the law survives the deal.

The supply argument is also contested, with studies commissioned by the advocacy groups. Huong Nguyen of Environmental Defense Fund Europe cites a study by Rystad Energy finding that the volume of gas worldwide that is ready to meet the requirements is more than three times what the EU imports, and a study by Carbon Limits estimating that full compliance would cost producers less than 1% of the value of their output.

Pablo Lopez Legarreta of the Clean Air Task Force puts measuring, reporting and verifying at between 0.03% and 0.6% of gas production costs.

The people who gain are easy to name: importers and producers who now have until 2029 for the first verification duty. The people who bear the cost are harder to count, because every year without verified import data is a year in which the EU cannot tell clean gas from leaky gas. The only figure in the record comes from the Clean Air Task Force, an advocacy group, which says every year of slippage costs another 1 to 2 million tonnes of methane.

What the record shows is a sequence. A note from twelve governments in June, a letter from a US cabinet member and three gas exporters in the same month, a presidential letter in September, a one-year proposal in October, a three-year vote in Parliament, and a two-year compromise in November. Each step moved the dates in one direction. Until the formal votes, the law’s own text still says 2027.

BASIS OF ANALYSIS

Basis of analysis. The analysis rests on eight sources, of which one is an official Council document and the others are media reports that reproduce Council, Commission and Parliament statements. The Council and Commission press releases themselves could not be read, so the dates of the deal come through the outlets that quote them, and the new date for the maximum intensity limits could not be confirmed. The cost studies cited come from advocacy groups and were not reviewed independently.

Independent journalism

ExtraFokus is ad-free, and that costs money

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu: €8/month.

No comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Become a Citizen Journalist

Seventeen free lessons in finding stories, checking facts, writing and treating people fairly.