The climate summit in Antalya opened on 9 November, and the two COP31 hosts both lean on coal. Türkiye’s environment minister Murat Kurum holds the COP31 presidency. Australia’s Chris Bowen runs the negotiations. Neither has offered a coal exit, and Europe should stop treating that as a detail.
Table of contents
What the COP31 hosts offer
Start with the numbers. Urgewald’s Global Coal Exit List 2026 shows coal supplying 34% of Türkiye’s electricity in 2025, while wind and solar together supplied 22%. The same report puts Turkish coal subsidies above €2.4 billion a year. Urgewald is a campaign group, and these are its figures.
Climate Action Tracker puts coal and gas together at 56% of Turkish power in 2025, barely changed since 2019. In Australia fossil fuels supply over 60% of electricity, coal alone 45%, and the country is the world’s third-largest fossil fuel exporter.
Urgewald counts 49 proposed Australian mines or extensions, 20 of them greenfield. On 30 September New South Wales approved extending the Hunter Valley Operations mine to 2045, allowing about 429 million tonnes of coal. Federal approval is still pending. Australia is among the few OECD countries without a coal phase-out date.
Read also: Europe should tax billionaires on what they emit
The pledge that skips coal
The Turkish presidency’s headline offer is a voluntary goal: electricity at 35% of final energy consumption by 2035. Kurum says electrification will “lead to a reduction in the use of fossil fuels”. He has also confirmed that his Action Agenda contains no explicit initiative on moving away from them.
Heffa Schücking, Urgewald’s director, answers with an image: “Electrification without phasing out coal is like showering with polluted water.” I would add a fact from the same report. Kurum’s own ministry is appealing a court ruling that overturned the environmental assessment for new units at the Afşin-Elbistan coal plant.
Climate Action Tracker adds that Türkiye’s own plan projects electrification reaching only 25% of final energy by 2035, against a global target of 35%. The presidency’s August action plan, in turn, makes no explicit pledge to phase out or phase down fossil fuels. A voluntary 35% goal sits on top of both.
A president who defends new coal units in court while launching an electrification pledge is selling a plug with no plan behind it.
Who holds the pen
Kurum insists that “Türkiye and Australia are not co-presidents” and that the final decision lies with the COP31 presidency. The summit’s official modalities give the Australian representative exclusive authority over the negotiations. So the text that matters, the cover decision, is Bowen’s to draft.
Australia’s list of likely items for that text covers the 1.5C overshoot, electrification, methane, early warning, finance and nature, but names no transition away from fossil fuels. Brazil’s voluntary fossil fuel roadmap, unveiled on 3 November, runs to 182 pages with three stages to 2033 and national transition plans by 2028. Brazilian officials say it is not a negotiated document.
Read also: Sanctions deserve less credit than we claim
That is why the cover decision matters: it is the text every government signs. Europe and small island states might push to reference the roadmap there.
Kurum himself concedes that holding warming to 1.5C is “no longer possible” and says limiting it to “around 1.5C” would count as success. A target that soft needs a hard exit from coal behind it, and nobody in the host team has offered one.
What Europe brings to Antalya
On 12 October EU environment ministers approved conclusions saying the Union will call for the transition away from fossil fuels, with clean electrification as an important component. Good. But Europe arrives with no new climate finance, which leaves it one currency: its position on the text.
So I would spend it. Brussels should tell the hosts that it will back the electrification goal only if the cover decision also names the fossil fuel transition and the roadmap. That is a modest price. It asks the presidency to write down what the Council already wrote down in Luxembourg.
Europe also has to accept what the demand costs. It cannot ask two coal-reliant hosts for an exit while treating its own electrification language as the ceiling of ambition. Either the text names fossil fuels or the summit will have shown that hosting a COP is the cheapest way to control one.
Sources
- Climate Home News: Türkiye says it has “final decision” at COP31 (11 Sep 2026) – Kurum on roles, the modalities document and the Action Agenda.
- Climate Home News: Fossil fuel expansion threatens COP31 hosts’ credibility (18 Sep 2026) – Climate Action Tracker and Climate Analytics figures on both hosts.
- Eco-Business: COP31 hosts pursue coal expansion, Urgewald report (26 Oct 2026) – Urgewald’s coal pipeline, subsidy and mine figures.
- Climate Home News: COP31 briefing, what to expect (5 Nov 2026) – dates, electrification pledge, cover decision and roadmap.
- Lovguiden: EU states set negotiating position for COP31 (12 Oct 2026) – summary of the Council conclusions.















