Ukraine faces a shortfall of €70 billion in 2027, and the EU has promised about two thirds of it, about €45 billion, through an instrument that does not yet exist. Chancellor Friedrich Merz has now tied Germany’s approval of the 2028 to 2034 EU budget to a solution “supported by all member states”. At the same time Berlin is pushing for a design that would make future Ukraine aid harder for any single government to stop.
Table of contents
Both moves follow from one fact about EU money: the long-term budget needs every government to say yes, and Hungary, Slovakia, Czechia and Bulgaria have said they will not pay more.
The letter that links two fights
In a letter to European Council President António Costa, Merz asks for “a sound and multiannual financing perspective for Ukraine from 2028 onwards” and makes the budget deal conditional on the extra €45 billion. He wants the question handled as a priority at the informal summit in Dublin. The letter has been reported as a threat to block the 2028 to 2034 budget unless all member states help close the gap.
The reaction shows how awkward the link is. Irish finance minister Simon Harris, whose country holds the rotating presidency, sided with the budget-minded “frugal” countries and said it is “very hard to have a serious conversation” on the budget without settling Ukraine first. Poland’s deputy minister for European affairs, Ignacy Niemczycki, warned that tying the two could “backfire”. Slovak prime minister Robert Fico called such a link “very dangerous”.
Berlin’s own record complicates the demand. In July 2025 a spokesman for the German government, Stefan Cornelius, said Germany could not accept the Commission’s budget proposal, which then allowed €100 billion for Ukraine within a central budget of €1.816 trillion.
What the treaty says about vetoes
The legal frame is short. Under Article 312 of the EU treaty, the Council adopts the multiannual budget framework by unanimity, after Parliament gives its consent by a majority of its members. The same article contains a bridge clause: the European Council can decide, again unanimously, that the Council may adopt the framework by qualified majority.
Read also: Merz links EU budget to Ukraine aid
Parliament is a second gate, because its consent is also required. No source used for this analysis reports Parliament’s position on the Ukraine reserve.
So the budget itself keeps its veto for every government, and no source describes a plan to change that.
What Berlin proposes concerns the money inside the budget. Politico reported on 19 November that Berlin wants the EU to hold a reserve that could raise further money for Ukraine above the €100 billion the Commission has proposed, through a loan mechanism that avoids large upfront spending. Unanimity would still be needed to approve the new budget and the reserve. Later decisions to draw Ukraine funds from it would need only a qualified majority.
A report in the Financial Times describes the same aim: future decisions on Ukraine funding by qualified majority, a lower bar than unanimity. A German official says Ukraine support from all member states is “essential”. The proposal is not settled, and Berlin has taken no final decision on the voting rule.
The Le Pen clause
The political reason is stated in that reporting. Berlin wants a mechanism that is harder to block for opponents of Ukraine aid, “in particular Marine Le Pen”, who hopes to become French president. EU sources say Le Pen could win the presidential election in April.
On 16 November Le Pen met Ukraine’s ambassador. She was reported as saying that France would honour existing commitments, including the €90 billion loan, but take on no new ones, citing public finances. Macron is reported to have named mid-January 2027 as the deadline for agreement on the budget.
The Politico report adds three further points. Merz’s letter is read as an implicit threat to cut German contributions to regional development funds that benefit sceptical central European countries if they try to block the reserve.
A Commission official says Merz wants the EU budget to cover more than €40 billion of interest due on existing loans to Ukraine, which would consume a large part of the €100 billion proposed. And the far-right AfD, ahead of Merz’s conservatives in polls, criticises him for spending money on Ukraine when it could be spent at home.
German European affairs minister Gunther Krichbaum says Ukraine funding must be reliable and part of the multiannual framework. Merz said in Berlin that Ukraine policy must be fully included in the EU budget, standing next to Hungary’s prime minister Péter Magyar.
Read also: Two Dublin Summits Precede the EU’s Budget Showdown
Who already has an exit
A senior EU official quoted in the Politico report says funding for Ukraine is more contested than ever, and more so if Le Pen wins in April. An EU diplomat says the need for unanimity makes no sense in today’s geopolitical world. German officials also fear that letting small states such as Slovakia stay out of Ukraine funding would set a precedent that larger ones, France under Le Pen among them, could use to avoid future commitments.
Hungary, Slovakia and Czechia hold an opt-out from the €90 billion loan “in exchange for providing the necessary unanimity”, and they demand the same right for any new Ukraine aid. Bulgaria is named among the governments that refuse to contribute. The opt-outs show how unanimity works in practice: a government can stay out of a payment and still decide whether the payment happens.
That is the structure Berlin is trying to change, at least for Ukraine. A qualified majority would let a coalition of governments approve each draw-down while the sceptics keep their budget vote. It would also remove the leverage that opt-outs bought in the first place.
The open questions on Ukraine aid
Three things remain unclear. The first is the legal form: whether a reserve with majority draw-down fits inside the budget regulation that the Council must adopt unanimously, and who sets the rules for the draw-down. No source opened for this analysis shows the draft text.
The second is the price. The Commission puts the 2027 gap at €70 billion, of which about €45 billion would come through the new instrument, and the long-term budget could reach €2 trillion. How much of that Berlin would route through the reserve is not stated.
The third is the clock. An extraordinary summit is planned for 26 and 27 November, and the gap in 2027 opens before any new budget exists. A veto by a future French government would only matter if the money still depends on a decision in 2028 or later. Berlin’s stated aim is to lock the mechanism in before the French election, so that a new government cannot undo it by a single veto.
BASIS OF ANALYSIS
Basis of analysis. The analysis rests on eight sources: the treaty text on the budget procedure and seven media reports, several of which pass on accounts first published elsewhere, among them a Czech translation of the Politico report. Neither Merz’s letter nor the draft German proposal could be read, so the voting design is described as reported and not confirmed from a primary text.
Sources
- legislation.gov.uk: Article 312 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union – the unanimity and consent rules for the multiannual budget framework and the bridge clause.
- Euronews: No deal on Ukraine aid, then no deal on EU budget, Merz says (9 November 2026) – documents Merz’s letter and the reactions from Ireland, Poland and Slovakia.
- Britské listy: Germany pushes to make Ukraine aid Le Pen-proof (20 November 2026, Czech translation of Politico) – documents the reserve, the majority-vote design, the interest costs and the objections.
- České noviny (ČTK): Germany wants to ensure Ukraine aid is not blocked by Le Pen (19 November 2026) – documents the reserve, the voting rules and the objecting governments.
- United24 Media: Merz uses EU budget talks to secure long-term funding for Ukraine (9 to 10 November 2026) – reproduces the Financial Times account of the demand for majority voting.
- Yeni Şafak (Anadolu): German chancellor threatens to block EU budget (10 November 2026) – documents the veto wording and the governments that refuse to contribute.
- Kurs: Germany wants to protect aid to Ukraine from political changes in France (November 2026) – reproduces reports on Le Pen’s meeting with the Ukrainian ambassador and Macron’s deadline.
- UNN: Germany rejected the EU budget plan that envisioned €100 billion for Ukraine (17 July 2025) – documents the Commission’s 2025 proposal and Berlin’s rejection.

















