Live-In Carers Work Where Europe’s Inspectors Cannot Enter

Live-in carers work in private homes where labour inspectors cannot enter

If an elderly relative needs round-the-clock care at home, the person who moves in to provide it works in a place that labour inspectors in many EU countries can enter only with the occupant’s consent or a court order, and in Austria not at all. The European Labour Authority (ELA) set this out in a report on the long-term care sector published in April 2026, and live-in care is where the gap is widest.

Table of contents
  1. The inspector waits at the front door
  2. The undeclared share is a guess
  3. Austria pays for live-in care it cannot inspect
  4. Posting turns one household into a contract chain
  5. The privacy objection is real and answerable
  6. The fix on offer is gradual

Read also: Brussels Weighs Human Checks on Algorithmic Management

The report counts over 3.2 million long-term care workers in the EU-27 in 2024, about 1.6% of all employment. More than 86% are women and over 40% are aged 50 or older. Nearly 14% are mobile workers from EU or EFTA countries or nationals of non-EU countries, and in home-based personal care that share is almost one quarter.

The inspector waits at the front door

The report lists what inspectors may do when the workplace is a home. In Germany, inspection of private households is possible only if the owner has given consent. Ireland requires the homeowner’s consent or a District Court warrant. Belgian social inspectors need prior authorisation from an investigating judge, and in Italy access is restricted by the constitution and the Code of Criminal Procedure.

On Austria the report is blunt: “Labour inspectors are not permitted to enter private homes.” The report calls the inability to access private households the greatest enforcement challenge in domestic care, and cites a 2022 study by Hiessl that puts the likelihood of a household facing enforcement proceedings at “vanishingly small”.

The undeclared share is a guess

What inspectors cannot see, nobody counts. The report repeats an ELA estimate from 2021 that at least 6.8 million people in the EU work undeclared in personal and household services, and puts the incidence of undeclared employment in the care sector at about 35%.

Country figures show the scale. For Italy the report cites 2022 data from the national statistics and social insurance institutes: of 1.86 million domestic workers and carers, more than half, 1.03 million, are undeclared. For Germany it says around 300,000 to 350,000 undeclared live-in care workers may be employed in households, and that precise figures are missing.

Estonia, Latvia and Norway have low undeclared rates, and the report describes their long-term care as more regulated and publicly provided. For Spain it notes that live-in care is mostly done by foreign or dual nationals, 87.4% of them from outside the EU.

Austria pays for live-in care it cannot inspect

Austria shows what a state does when it wants the arrangement to work. The social ministry subsidises 24-hour care with up to 800 euros a month toward two self-employed carers, for households with care allowance level 3 or higher and a net income below 2,500 euros a month. In 2024 federal and regional governments spent more than 220 million euros on the scheme, for an average of 22,200 people a month, the ministry says.

Almost all live-in carers in Austria work as self-employed individuals, the ELA report says. The ministry’s brochure limits actual work to 11 hours a day. The labour inspectorate that would normally check such a limit has no right of entry.

Since October 2018 every recipient of the subsidy gets mandatory home visits, up to four times a year. Those visits check the quality of care.

Posting turns one household into a contract chain

In Germany the report estimates that two thirds of regularly employed live-in care workers are engaged via posting, meaning a foreign employer sends them to work temporarily. A direct contract with the household is rather rare because of the high costs, the report says. The work usually runs through agencies and contracts of mandate, with instructions coming only from the posting company.

The Polish National Labour Inspectorate described in 2024 “dual contract arrangements”, in which two civil-law mandate contracts are signed with the carer. The report says they create artificial breaks in the posting and blur which employer is responsible.

A German court case shows what is at stake. In June 2021 the Federal Labour Court ruled on a Bulgarian carer employed by a company in Bulgaria and posted to a household in Berlin. Her contract said 30 hours a week, while the questionnaire for the household listed 24-hour care. The court held that the statutory minimum wage covers on-call time as well as full work, and sent the case back to the lower court.

Some enforcement does happen. A Dutch investigation in 2020 reclassified bogus self-employed live-in carers as employees, and a German customs case in 2024 involved at least 2.2 million euros in unpaid contributions.

Read also: Pensions Are Europe’s Next Generational Fight

The privacy objection is real and answerable

Protecting the home is the reason given for the limits, and the international rule agrees with it. Article 17 of the ILO Domestic Workers Convention of 2011 says inspection measures must specify the conditions under which access to household premises may be granted, “having due respect for privacy”.

Denmark’s inspectorate may inspect households under the same conditions as any other workplace, the report says, yet it mostly inspects households with visible renovation works and rarely home care. A legal right of entry does not by itself produce inspections.

The report points to a middle route. Visits that focus on care quality might also be used to obtain information on working conditions, it says, but only if legal and institutional conditions are established. Austria already visits every subsidised household, so the missing piece there is a legal mandate to ask the carer about hours and pay.

The fix on offer is gradual

ELA’s recommendations are modest. It asks labour authorities to pay more attention to the sector, to run awareness campaigns for households that may not recognise their duties as formal employers, and to pursue “the gradual development of legislative mandates and operational capacity”.

Care is the priority sector for ELA activities in 2026. The #EUFairCare campaign targets mobile workers, employers and the self-employed in long-term care and runs in two phases, April to June and October to December 2026.

One binding deadline does exist for part of the problem. The Platform Work Directive (2024/2831) must be transposed by 2 December 2026, and the report calls it particularly important for care platforms, which it describes as enablers of undeclared care work. In Spain, platforms already must cooperate with labour authorities, but data is shared only when inspectors ask.

The report projects that the number of dependent people will rise by more than 41% between 2022 and 2040. Its answer for the front door is gradual.

BASIS OF ANALYSIS

Basis of analysis. The analysis rests on seven sources, four of them primary or official: the ELA report, the ILO convention text, the German court’s case page and the Austrian ministry documents. The undeclared-work figures are estimates that the ELA report takes from earlier studies, and the ELA chapters on information provision and the annexes were not used.

Independent journalism

ExtraFokus is ad-free, and that costs money

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu: €8/month.

No comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Become a Citizen Journalist

Seventeen free lessons in finding stories, checking facts, writing and treating people fairly.