Independent Media Has Become the Kremlin’s Mask

Independent Media Has Become the Kremlin's Mask

“I only trust independent media.”

Table of contents
  1. Research in a circle
  2. Who pays the bill
  3. The mask is cheap
  4. Editors do the work
  5. No free media in Russia
  6. Three questions

People say it with pride, convinced that it makes them critical thinkers. I don’t understand it. Adults read a text that confirms everything they already believed, call it research, and look down on everyone who watches the evening news. They picked the independents, after all.

The word has been hijacked.

I am a trained journalist and I run an outlet with no state funding, no advertisers and nobody above me. If anyone has the right to say independent, it is me. That is why I can’t stand watching the word stick to outlets that are paid by the Kremlin.

Critical thinking is a method. Distrust is a feeling, and it is free, because it requires no work. A person who distrusts every public broadcaster and every news agency, yet never asks who stands behind the source that agrees with him, has a mood and calls it a tool.

Research in a circle

Most of these people believe they do research. That is the heart of it. They search, they read three pages, and all three say the same thing. It feels like three sources. I see a circle.

The Pravda network has no newsroom to speak of. The American Sunlight Project describes its defining trait as a lack of original content, because it republishes only from other pro-Russian sources. NewsGuard calls it a laundering operation that pushes material from Russian state outlets, pro-Kremlin influencers and officials through sites that look independent.

Bloggers and commentators link to the laundromat. The Institute for Strategic Dialogue (ISD) found that more than 75 percent of the sites it reviewed were commentary, personal blogs included. Search engines read links as a sign of trust, so the texts rise to the top when a curious person types in a question.

Three sites quoting each other are one source, washed three times.

Research means going where it hurts. A person who only reads sites that fit his worldview has assembled a collection and called it an investigation. He picked the filter himself, and the filter is named independent media. Nothing can contradict him, because anything that could has been sorted out as mainstream.

Read also: Europe's Free Press Is Dying Quietly

Who pays the bill

RT reportedly received 28.6 billion rubles from the Russian state in 2024. When a state pays the bill and decides the content, I call that a state outlet, whatever it calls itself. The EU suspended the broadcasting of RT and Sputnik on 2 March 2022.

I know the objection. Public broadcasters across Europe also get state money. They do. A journalist at one of them can expose a government without being declared an undesirable organisation. Try that in Moscow.

News Front describes itself as an alternative source of information with objective coverage in ten languages. The US Treasury sanctioned it twice, in April 2021 and March 2022. A 2020 report from the US State Department quotes a former employee saying that Putin’s office hands out the assignments directly.

So the sender is known. The word independent gets used anyway, because it works on readers who have been taught to distrust everything else.

The mask is cheap

In 2022, EU DisinfoLab exposed that at least 17 media outlets, Bild and ANSA among them, had been cloned with fake domains and identical design. That was the Doppelganger operation, and it looks almost handmade today.

NewsGuard published a report on 28 September 2026 counting 906 fabricated reports styled as legitimate outlets since the full-scale invasion, and it found Russian operations now impersonating well-known European broadcasters. Analysts tracking the Storm-1516 operation say it produced fake stories at twice the rate in the first quarter of 2026 as a year earlier.

Internal papers from Russia’s Social Design Agency, 73 of them dated 2023 to 2026, describe plans for sites that imitate encyclopedias, media outlets and think tanks, aimed at search results and language models.

German authorities attributed a fake video, released days before the 6 September 2026 election in Saxony-Anhalt and meant to discredit postal voting, to Storm-1516. They link the operation to Russian military intelligence.

Editors do the work

The Pravda network barely has readers of its own. NewsGuard measured its English-language site at about 955 unique visitors a month. Yet ISD found 919 sites linking to the network between July 2024 and July 2025.

Of the 303 English-language sites it examined, 81 percent treated the network as a credible source. Only 3 percent told readers what it is, a Russian propaganda machine. Among large sites with more than a million monthly visitors, only NewsGuard put the link in context.

I find that embarrassing for my profession. Newsrooms full of trained journalists do the machine’s work for it.

The counter-evidence deserves space. Direct traffic is tiny, and ISD noted that AI chatbots rarely cite the network’s pages. A network nobody visits sounds harmless. I read the numbers differently. It was built to be linked, and the links are where it lives.

Read also: Romania blames Russia after drone sinks cargo ship

And it grows. Researchers who follow the network put its output at up to 23,000 articles a day in May 2025, against roughly 6,000 a day in 2024. ISD senior researcher Joseph Bodnar calls it a numbers game: saturate the web so the network lands in front of anyone researching Russia.

It reaches well beyond the war. About 40 percent of the linking sites mentioned Russia or Ukraine in the headline, and 15 percent were about American politics.

Pravda does not need to convince anybody. It needs a link, and the editors do the rest.

No free media in Russia

Since the invasion, every independent outlet inside Russia has been closed or has stopped work. Those that continue from exile, such as Meduza and Dozhd, have been declared undesirable by Russia’s prosecutor general, which exposes journalists, staff and donors to prosecution.

The media that are truly independent of Putin are banned in his own country. The others reach us through copies, links and shared posts, and call themselves independent.

Three questions

On 8 October 2026 the Council of the EU extended its restrictive measures against Russian hybrid activities, including information manipulation, until 9 October 2027. The measures cover 80 individuals and 20 entities, with asset freezes and travel bans.

A travel ban cannot reach a reader’s habits.

I have no patent on the word independent. Ask three questions of any source, mine included. Who pays? Who owns it? Can I see the sources, and does the outlet correct its errors openly?

If the answers are missing, the independence is missing too. The Council will review its list again before 9 October 2027. Your three questions take ten seconds and need no mandate.

Opinion pieces on ExtraFokus.eu reflect the views of their authors.

Independent journalism

ExtraFokus is ad-free, and that costs money

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu: €8/month.

No comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Become a Citizen Journalist

Seventeen free lessons in finding stories, checking facts, writing and treating people fairly.