Joshua Wong’s crime was asking for sanctions

Joshua Wong gets ten years

On Thursday a Hong Kong judge added ten years to Joshua Wong’s prison term for asking foreign governments to impose sanctions. A man is jailed for the content of a request to other countries, and the countries asked are expected to say nothing. I do not intend to say nothing, and neither should anyone in Brussels who claims to defend human rights.

Table of contents
  1. The crime is the request
  2. Beijing calls it futile
  3. What Europe owes Joshua Wong

The crime is the request

The charge was conspiring with the exiled activist Nathan Law to collude with foreign forces between July and November 2020. Prosecutors described lobbying for a US sanctions law, including meetings with Nancy Pelosi and the then senator Marco Rubio. Wong pleaded guilty.

Judge William Tam called Wong and Law “ring-leaders or masterminds”, with Wong in a supporting role. His reasons for calling the offence grave include that the pair met foreign officials, called for sanctions or blockades, and spread those calls through Western mainstream media. Read the last part again. Spreading a political demand through newspapers now counts as part of the aggravation.

Tam began at 13 years and took three off for the guilty plea and mitigation. Ten years, the court said, is the minimum for an offence of this gravity under Article 29 of the national security law, which allows life. Two months and two days of the term run alongside his existing sentence. Wong had been due out in January, after four years and eight months in the 2024 subversion case. That date is gone.

Read also: Xi’s purges expose Europe’s bet on Beijing

His own lawyer, Derek Chan, had conceded in September that the sentence could be up to ten years and asked the court to halve it. The court gave him the top of what his defence expected, and the hope the lawyer asked for did not make it into the verdict.

Beijing calls it futile

Steve Li, chief superintendent of the National Security Department, welcomed the sentence and said it “evidently proved” that Wong’s efforts to rouse foreign sanctions were “futile”. The Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun told critics to “stop making irresponsible remarks regarding the trial of HKSAR judicial cases”.

Futile is a claim about Europe as much as about Wong. The police chief is betting that governments will take the request, shrug and move on. Jimmy Lai was given 20 years under the same law in February. Now Wong gets ten more. Each sentence is a test of what the outside world will tolerate, and Beijing is betting on the answer.

The court’s own case deserves a hearing. It holds that the sanctions the pair sought seriously endangered national security, and that they carried on after the law took effect. I read the same facts differently. A sanction is a decision taken by a foreign government. The person who asks for one has made no such decision, and nothing in the court’s reasons says Wong could have forced a single one.

Steve Tsang of SOAS University of London said before the sentencing that there was “no scope for turning back to the more relaxed days before 2019”. The verdict confirms it. The only open question is what the rest of the world does with that knowledge.

Read also: EU adds €2 parcel fee to €3 duty

What Europe owes Joshua Wong

Human Rights Watch called the sentence “cruel and unjust” and urged foreign governments to “impose targeted sanctions on officials responsible for Hong Kong’s growing repression”. Wong went to prison for asking governments to do what a rights group now asks of them. If European capitals answer with a statement of concern, they will have told Hong Kong’s courts that the request was an offence and the punishment merely regrettable.

A statement of concern costs nothing, and Beijing has priced it in. Its foreign ministry has already told the critics what to do with their remarks. Words are the one response the system has shown it can wave away.

Sanctions would not open Wong’s cell door, and I do not pretend otherwise. They would answer the claim that his request was futile, which is the claim the police chief says the sentence has proved. That answer is worth more than another communique, and it is within the reach of the same governments that praise the right to petition.

Hong Kong has set the price of asking at ten years. Brussels and the capitals still have to set the price of that sentence.

SOURCES & METHOD

How this article was made. The article rests on four sources, none of them the judgment itself. Reactions from European governments could not be confirmed and are left out.

Independent journalism

ExtraFokus is ad-free, and that costs money

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu: €8/month.

No comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles right away!

Support ExtraFokus

Be one of the first 100 members of ExtraFokus.eu. No ads, no media group, just readers like you.

Become a Citizen Journalist

Seventeen free lessons in finding stories, checking facts, writing and treating people fairly.