Asylum seekers who first entered the EU through Italy and then moved north can be sent back there under EU rules. Italy stopped accepting these asylum returns in December 2022, and the Commission now says that continued refusal would amount to a systemic shortcoming under the EU migration pact. Rome says transfers have resumed.
Table of contents
A court ruling Rome cannot announce away
At the end of 2022 Italy told other states it would no longer accept transfers under the old Dublin rules, with exceptions. A German court sent the resulting case to the EU’s Court of Justice. Germany had asked Italy in April 2023 to take charge of an asylum seeker, Italy never replied, and Italy was therefore deemed to have accepted.
The Court first said so in December 2024 and repeated it on 5 March 2026: a state cannot discharge its duties “by a mere unilateral announcement”. If a transfer does not happen within six months, responsibility passes to the state that asked, whatever the reason. The Court added that the Commission or any other member state may bring an action for failure to fulfil obligations.
The Commission counted twelve refusals
The Commission’s assessment of 15 July 2026 records that Italy suspended receiving transfers in December 2022, except for family reunification of unaccompanied minors, and that the circulars behind the suspension have not been formally revoked. Between 12 June and 7 July, 12 transfers were requested and Italy rejected them. One transfer took place, based on a request confirmed before 12 June.
Under the pact a receiving state “may not reject a transfer” and must propose another date. The Commission says Italy must remove the remaining impediments “as a matter of priority”. It also sees no indications that the Italian authorities had actively engaged on the practical steps to resume transfers.
The same assessment credits Italy with significant preparation, including a reinforced national unit and designated transfer locations.
Read also: Europe’s New Migration Rules Turn Borders Into Waiting Rooms
Rome says it resumed, Brussels keeps counting
A Commission decision of 6 November records that Italy adopted a new administrative letter on 29 October. The letter states that Italy has resumed transfers since 12 June, assessed case by case. The same decision says transfers requested by other states “continued to be rejected” by the Italian authorities, and that some transfers and family reunifications of minors did take place.
The decision also says Italian authorities returned some people to the transferring states even though Italy had been determined responsible, and changed the default locations for transfers, citing internal organisation and the risk of absconding.
The Commission calls the letter one of several “encouraging developments” that need close monitoring. If non-compliance continues without a lasting remedy, the decision says, it “would amount to systemic shortcomings” under the pact’s solidarity rules. Under those rules, states that pledged help to a country with such shortcomings are not required to deliver it.
Italy is one of four states the same decision lists as under migratory pressure, which gives it access to the EU’s annual solidarity pool. It accounted for 42% of persons disembarked in the EU.
Do asylum returns cover old cases
The pact applies from 12 June 2026. Berlin and Vienna say it covers people who arrived before that date as well. Rome says it covers only those who entered after it, and Italian interior ministry sources describe older cases as “written off” for some countries including Germany, under a deal the two governments signed in December 2025.
Germany scheduled its first transfer under the pact for 19 August, a 22-year-old Somali woman. Berlin had sent the request in June, Italy did not answer within two weeks, and Berlin treated that as tacit consent. Austria says it has sent four people back.
Read also: Europe Legalised Return Hubs Before Naming a Host
What Brussels can actually do
The Commission’s own route is monitoring. It will ask Italy and the other member states for information at least every three months and report to the pact’s solidarity forums. If the practice persists, it goes to the High-Level Solidarity Forum and then to the Council. A final finding is due at the latest with the Commission’s annual decision in 2027, and the present decision applies from 1 January 2027.
The Court has named a harder tool, an action for failure to fulfil obligations, which the Commission or any member state may bring. Until someone uses it, the instrument with a date on it is a quarterly information request.
SOURCES & METHOD
How this article was made. The article rests on six sources, three of them official documents, none of them the pact’s text itself. A figure for Germany’s outgoing requests differed between sources and was left out.
Sources
- Court of Justice of the EU: Press release No 28/26, Case C-458/24 (5 Mar 2026) – the ruling on unilateral suspension of transfers and the infringement route.
- European Commission: Assessment, COM(2026) 387 final (15 Jul 2026) – Italy’s suspension, the 12 rejected requests and the Commission’s position.
- Council of the EU: ST 15559/26, transmitting Commission Implementing Decision C(2026) 8350 (6 Nov 2026) – Italy’s 29 October letter, the Commission’s reading and the monitoring steps.
- Il Sole 24 Ore: Hardline stance on migrants in Germany, deportations from Italy (9 Aug 2026) – the “written off” cases and the first German transfer.
- EU Perspectives: Eight EU states turn on Rome as an old migration fight returns (2 Sep 2026) – the dispute over arrivals before 12 June.
- ANSA: Vienna also sends Dubliners back to Italy after Berlin and Bern (20 Aug 2026) – Austrian transfers.

















